Head to head · September 2026 cycle
Penlify vs Phrasly
Phrasly finished 31.0 points ahead of Penlify in the September 2026 cycle, 67.58 to 36.57, ranking #8 against #14 in a field of 14. Phrasly scored higher on 5 of 5 detectors and 7 of 7 writing categories. Penlify came out ahead on consistency across categories (100.0 vs 75.0), penalties (−5.0 vs −6.0) and readability (71.8 vs 65.4).
- Detectors
- 0 – 5
- Categories
- 0 – 7
- Components
- 3 – 2
33 prompts · Last tested · Methodology v1.2.0
Score components
What the overall score is made of: bypass rate weighs 42%, meaning preservation 32%, readability 16%, consistency across categories 10%. Output-quality penalties come off the total. How scoring works →
CIs overlap marks a gap that sits inside both tools' published 95% confidence intervals for that component; it may not survive another cycle.
Detector by detector
Share of each tool's outputs that a detector classified as human-written. Phrasly took 5 of 5.
Writing categories
Category score per writing context: bypass credit only for real rewrites, blended with the category's own meaning preservation and readability. Small categories swing; the prompt count is shown on each row. How category scores work →
Where each one wins
Every measure above that one tool won outright, largest margin first within each group.
Penlify
3 wins- Consistency Score 100.0 vs 75.0
- Penalties Score −5.0 vs −6.0
- Readability Score 71.8 vs 65.4
Phrasly
14 wins- Bypass rate Score 82.1 vs 0.0
- Meaning preservation Score 66.1 vs 62.7
- Originality.ai Detector 83.4 vs 0.0
- Copyleaks Detector 81.8 vs 0.0
- GPTZero Detector 81.4 vs 0.0
- Winston AI Detector 61.6 vs 0.4
- ZeroGPT Detector 68.0 vs 43.0
- Application Essay Category 78.1 vs 35.9
- News Article Category 78.3 vs 36.6
- Academic Essay Category 64.5 vs 27.0
- and 4 more
Same prompt, both outputs
Both tools were given this AI-written passage in the September 2026 cycle. Below it is what each one returned. This prompt was picked by a fixed rule, not by how the tools scored.
AI-written input
Every tool on this prompt →Howto Blog · Blog Post · written by Gemini 3.5 Flash · 454 words
**The Weekend Warrior’s Guide to a Small Bathroom Renovation**
Renovating a small bathroom doesn’t require weeks of chaos. With a tight plan, a clear budget, and 48 hours of focused effort, you can transform your compact space from dated to dazzling. Here is your step-by-step weekend battle plan.
### **The Prep Work (Do This Before Friday)** Success lies in preparation. Order all materials—paint, fixtures, vanity, and hardware—weeks in advance. Ensure everything is delivered and undamaged. Gather your tools: a drill, adjustable wrench, caulk gun, painter’s tape, and safety gear.
---
### **Saturday: Demo and Base Layers**
* **Morning: Out with the Old (8:00 AM – 12:00 PM)** Shut off the water valves. Remove the old mirror, hardware, and vanity. If you are replacing the toilet, drain it completely, unscrew the floor bolts, and lift it out. Seal the open drain pipe with a rag to block sewer gases. Bag all trash immediately to keep your workspace clear. * **Afternoon: Prep and Paint (1:00 PM – 5:00 PM)** Patch any drywall holes with quick-dry spackle, sand them smooth, and wipe the walls clean. Apply painter's tape to the trim. In a small bathroom, a fresh coat of moisture-resistant, semi-gloss paint in a light color (like soft white or pale gray) will instantly make the room feel double its size. Apply the first coat, wait two hours, and apply the second. * **Evening: Install the Vanity (6:00 PM – 9:00 PM)** Assemble your new vanity. Position it against the wall, ensure it is level, and secure it to the wall studs. Install the new faucet onto the vanity sink *before* mounting the sink to the cabinet—it is much easier than doing it from underneath. Secure the sink top with silicone caulk.
---
### **Sunday: Plumbing and Styling**
* **Morning: Connections and Throne (9:00 AM – 1:00 PM)** Hook up the vanity water lines and drain trap. Next, install your new toilet (or reinstall the old one) using a fresh wax ring. Tighten the bolts gently to avoid cracking the porcelain. Turn the water main back on and check all connections carefully for leaks. * **Afternoon: The Details (2:00 PM – 6:00 PM)** Hang your new mirror—ideally a large one to bounce light around the room. Replace dated light fixtures (turn off the breaker first!). Swap out old towel bars, toilet paper holders, and cabinet pulls for cohesive, modern hardware (matte black or brushed brass work wonders). * **Evening: Clean and Style** Scrape away old tub caulk and apply a fresh, clean bead of silicone. Lay down a plush bath mat, hang fresh towels, and add a small plant.
By Sunday night, your cramped, outdated bathroom will be a stylish, functional oasis—all completed in just one weekend.
Show the full input Show less
445 words (input 454)
**The Weekend Warrior's Guide to a Small Bathroom Renovation**
A full‑blown remodel can take weeks, but a tiny bathroom can get a makeover in a single weekend if you lock in a plan, set a budget and carve out 48 focused hours. By Sunday night the old, cramped room can feel surprisingly roomy and fresh.
**Prep (do it before Friday)** Order paint, fixtures, a vanity and all the little bits weeks ahead. Make sure everything arrives in one go and isn't cracked. Pull together a drill, an adjustable wrench, a caulk gun, painter's tape and a pair of gloves, nothing else you'll need.
**Saturday, morning, ripping out the old (8 AM‑12 PM)** Turn off the water valves first. Take down the mirror, the hardware and the old vanity. If the toilet's getting replaced, flush it empty, undo the floor bolts and lift it away. Toss a rag over the open drain pipe so sewer gases stay out. Bag the junk as you go so the floor stays clear.
**Saturday, afternoon, patch and paint (1 PM‑5 PM)** Fill any drywall holes with quick‑dry spackle, sand smooth and wipe the walls. Stick painter's tape along the trim. In a small bathroom a light‑colored, moisture‑resistant semi‑gloss paint does wonders, think soft white or pale gray. Roll on the first coat, wait a couple of hours, then go back for a second.
**Saturday, evening, vanity time (6 PM‑9 PM)** Put the new vanity together, press it up against the wall and make sure it sits level. Screw it into the studs. Hook the faucet onto the sink before you mount the sink to the cabinet, much easier than reaching under later. Seal the sink top with a bead of silicone.
**Sunday, morning, plumbing and throne (9 AM‑1 PM)** Connect the vanity's water lines and drain trap. Slip the new toilet (or the old one) into place with a fresh wax ring, tighten the bolts just enough not to crack the porcelain. Turn the main water back on and watch for any drips.
**Sunday, afternoon, the details (2 PM‑6 PM)** Hang a large mirror so light bounces around. Swap out dated light fixtures, remember to shut the breaker first. Replace towel bars, toilet‑paper holders and cabinet pulls with something modern; matte black or brushed brass look great.
**Sunday, evening, clean up and style** Scrape away the old tub caulk, then lay a smooth line of fresh silicone. Roll out a plush bath mat, drape fresh towels and put a small plant on the sill for a splash of life.
And just like that, by the time the weekend ends, your once‑cramped bathroom has turned into a tidy, functional little oasis.
Show the full output Show less
- GPTZero0.00caught
- Winston AI0.03caught
- ZeroGPT0.41caught
- Copyleaks0.00caught
- Originality.ai0.00caught
Passed 0 of 5 detectors.
Every Penlify run in September 2026 →532 words (input 454)
‘The Weekend Warrior’ Guide to Small Bathroom Remodel **Weekend warriors: we have a solution that will cure your cramped bath-ette without wrecking your whole weekend. In just 48 hours you can renovate your frustratingly tiny bathroom from drab to dazzling with a detailed game plan, a firm budget, and some serious DIY grit. Follow this battle plan for a weekend bathroom remodel. ** Plan of Attack: The Prep Work (Complete BEFORE Friday) You can’attack a remodel without a battle plan. Having everything you need picked out and on-order weeks ahead of time will ensure your project stays damage-free and on-budget. Schedule deliveries so that all of your materials will arrive by Thursday evening. (Paint, fixtures, vanity, hardware, etc.) You’ll also need to grab tools you already own (or pick up) a drill, adjustable wrench, caulk gun, painter’stape, and safety glasses. Saturday: Demo &/Base Layers 8:00AM – 12:00PM: Demolish! * Turn off the toilet and sink water valves. Remove the mirror, hardware, and vanity. If you’re installing a new toilet, empty the tank and bowl, unscrew the bolts attaching it to the floor, and lift it out (towel may help to grip the smooth porcelain). Plug the hole in your drain pipe with a rag (this keeps sewer gases from escaping) and bag all your trash. *Note* Before you rip everything out, consider taking photos for when you’come to style the bathroom later. You’ll need these for your mirror and electrical wiring locations. 1: 00PM – 5:00PM: Prep Time* Fill any drywall holes with quick drying spackle. Lightly sand and wipe away dust. Apply painter’stape to any trim you’like to avoid painting the edges. Paint! Washrooms are small. Just slap on one semi-gloss, moisture resistant coat of paint in a light color (we love cool whites and greige!) and watch your small space seem twice as big. Apply your first coat, wait two hours, then apply your second. 5:00PM – 9:00PM: Vanity Installation* Assemble your vanity. Dry fit it against the wall and make sure it is level. Secure it to your wall studs. Attach your new faucet to the vanity sink PORTABLE.BUILT-IN before securing it to the cabinet. Add your sink top and secure with silicone caulk to seal. Sunday: Plumbing and Finishing Touches 9:00AM – 1:00PM: Pipes and Thrones* Install your vanity water lines and drain trap. Install your new toilet (or reinstall your existing toilet) using a new wax ring. Tighten the toilet bolts carefully – you don’t want to crack your toilet! Turn the water main back on and check all connections for leaks. 2:00PM – 6:00PM: Everything else. * Hang that mirror up (get a big one to maximize light!) Replace outdated light fixtures (turn off your breaker first!) and install new hardware. Make sure your towel bars, toilet paper holders, and cabinet pulls all match and are modernized. We suggest matte black or brushed brass. 7: 00PM: Cleaning and Styling* Remove old tub/caulk and install new bead of silicone. Add a cushy bath mat, some fluffy towels, and don’t forget a plant. The Jungle Book ain’t got nothing on you. There you have it. You’ve learned how to remodel your bathroom in just one weekend. You’re welcome.
Show the full output Show less
- GPTZero1.00passed
- Winston AI1.00passed
- ZeroGPT0.83passed
- Copyleaks1.00passed
- Originality.ai1.00passed
Passed 5 of 5 detectors.
Every Phrasly run in September 2026 →Each chip is one detector's score for that output, from 0 (AI) to 1 (human). A score of 0.50 or higher counts as a pass and shows green; below that the detector caught it and the chip shows red.
Questions people ask
Is Penlify better than Phrasly?
Phrasly finished 31.0 points ahead of Penlify in the September 2026 cycle, 67.58 to 36.57, ranking #8 against #14 in a field of 14. Phrasly scored higher on 5 of 5 detectors and 7 of 7 writing categories. Both tools ran the same 33 prompts, scored by the same 5 detectors, under methodology v1.2.0; every input, output and verdict is published.
Which bypasses AI detectors better, Penlify or Phrasly?
Phrasly posted the higher bypass rate, 82.1 vs 0.0, and scored higher on 5 of 5 detectors. Phrasly led on GPTZero, Originality.ai, Copyleaks, Winston AI and ZeroGPT.
Do Penlify and Phrasly keep the original meaning?
Phrasly preserved meaning better, 66.1 vs 62.7 on our 0–100 similarity scale, though the confidence intervals overlap. On readability, Penlify rated higher, 71.8 vs 65.4. Penalties this cycle: Penlify −5.0, Phrasly −6.0.