Head to head · November 2026 cycle
Humbot vs Walter Writes
Humbot finished 3.4 points ahead of Walter Writes in the November 2026 cycle, 58.38 to 54.95, ranking #13 against #15 in a field of 16. Humbot scored higher on 3 of 6 detectors and 3 of 6 writing categories. Walter Writes came out ahead on news article prompts (55.3 vs 45.3), GPTZero (69.3 vs 63.4) and Originality.ai (9.5 vs 5.0). The bypass-rate gap, 55.2 to 54.4, sits inside both tools' 95% confidence intervals, so treat bypass as a draw.
- Detectors
- 3 – 2 (1 tie)
- Categories
- 3 – 3
- Components
- 4 – 0 (1 tie)
30 prompts · Last tested · Methodology v1.3.0
Score components
What the overall score is made of: bypass rate weighs 42%, meaning preservation 32%, readability 16%, consistency across categories 10%. Output-quality penalties come off the total. How scoring works →
CIs overlap marks a gap that sits inside both tools' published 95% confidence intervals for that component; it may not survive another cycle.
Detector by detector
Share of each tool's outputs that a detector classified as human-written. Humbot took 3 of 6, with 1 tied.
Writing categories
Category score per writing context: bypass credit only for real rewrites, blended with the category's own meaning preservation and readability. Small categories swing; the prompt count is shown on each row. How category scores work →
Head-to-head history
Overall score in every cycle both tools were tested. Humbot has finished ahead in 4 of 5 shared cycles.
| Cycle | Humbot | Walter Writes | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| November 2026 | 58.38 #13 | 54.95 #15 | ← 3.4 |
| October 2026 | 61.74 #13 | 63.53 #10 | → 1.8 |
| August 2026 | 66.95 #5 | 60.83 #9 | ← 6.1 |
| July 2026 | 66.42 #5 | 62.84 #7 | ← 3.6 |
| June 2026 | 80.28 #4 | 67.24 #10 | ← 13.0 |
Where each one wins
Every measure above that one tool won outright, largest margin first within each group.
Humbot
10 wins- Meaning preservation Score 77.5 vs 70.7
- Readability Score 69.3 vs 63.8
- Bypass rate Score 55.2 vs 54.4
- Consistency Score 93.0 vs 92.6
- Copyleaks Detector 91.8 vs 84.3
- Winston AI Detector 98.1 vs 92.5
- ZeroGPT Detector 72.8 vs 71.0
- Blog Post Category 60.2 vs 51.2
- Marketing Copy Category 51.6 vs 48.7
- Discussion Board Category 50.1 vs 48.1
Walter Writes
5 wins- GPTZero Detector 69.3 vs 63.4
- Originality.ai Detector 9.5 vs 5.0
- News Article Category 55.3 vs 45.3
- Academic Essay Category 49.8 vs 47.9
- Application Essay Category 62.0 vs 61.8
Same prompt, both outputs
Both tools were given this AI-written passage in the November 2026 cycle. Below it is what each one returned. This prompt was picked by a fixed rule, not by how the tools scored.
AI-written input
Every tool on this prompt →Cover Letter · Application Essay · written by claude-sonnet-5-5 · 410 words
[Your Name] [Your Address] | [City, State ZIP] | [Phone] | [Email]
[Date]
[Hiring Manager's Name] [Department Name] City of [City Name] [Address]
Dear [Hiring Manager's Name],
I am writing to apply for the Policy Analyst position with the City of [City Name]. With a master's degree in public policy and four years of experience evaluating programs and advising local decision-makers, I am eager to help [City Name] craft practical, evidence-based policies that improve residents' daily lives.
In my current role at the [Organization Name], I analyze housing, transportation, and public safety initiatives for a region of 300,000 residents. Last year, I led an evaluation of a rental assistance pilot that revealed administrative barriers preventing nearly 20 percent of eligible households from enrolling. My recommendations, which included simplifying the application and partnering with community organizations for outreach, were adopted by the county and increased enrollment by 35 percent within six months. This experience taught me that strong policy analysis must pair rigorous data with a clear understanding of how programs work on the ground.
I am skilled in quantitative and qualitative research methods, including cost-benefit analysis, survey design, and statistical modeling in R and Excel. Equally important, I know how to translate complex findings into concise briefs and presentations that busy elected officials, department heads, and residents can use. I have presented to city council committees and facilitated public workshops, and I value the give-and-take of hearing community concerns and incorporating them into recommendations.
I am particularly drawn to [City Name]'s commitment to [specific initiative, e.g., expanding affordable housing, its climate action plan, or its Vision Zero goals]. I would welcome the chance to contribute to this work, whether by analyzing budget tradeoffs, researching best practices in peer cities, or evaluating outcomes to ensure programs deliver on their promises. Working in local government appeals to me because the results of good policy are visible and immediate: safer streets, stable housing, and responsive services.
Collaboration is central to my approach. I have worked alongside engineers, budget officers, legal staff, and nonprofit leaders, and I understand that effective policy depends on building trust across departments and with the public. I am organized, deadline-driven, and comfortable managing multiple projects while maintaining accuracy and transparency.
Thank you for considering my application. I would welcome the opportunity to discuss how my skills and commitment to public service can support the City of [City Name]. I can be reached at [phone] or [email].
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
Show the full input Show less
520 words (input 410)
[Your Name]
[Your Address] | [City, State ZIP] | [Phone] | [Email]
[Date]
[Hiring Manager's Name]
[Department Name]
City of [City Name]
[Address]
Dear [Hiring Manager's Name],
I'm applying to be a Policy Analyst for the City of [City Name]. I've earned my Master's Degree in Public Policy and have worked for the last four years on program evaluations and advising on policy issues for local government. Therefore, I'm excited about the opportunity to assist [City Name] in developing effective, data-driven policies that will positively affect people's everyday lives.
In my present capacity at the [Organization Name], I evaluate housing, transportation, and public safety initiatives for a community of 300,000 residents. During last year, I conducted an assessment of a rental assistance pilot project that demonstrated that administrative barriers prevented almost 20% of eligible participants from registering. As a result of my recommendations, such as streamlining the application process and collaborating with local community organizations to promote the pilot project, the County implemented these changes and increased participation in the pilot project by 35% in six months. This project has demonstrated to me that effective policy analysis requires both the use of rigorous data analysis along with a thorough understanding of how public programs operate at the grass-roots level.
I have experience using both quantitative and qualitative research methodologies; such as cost benefit analyses, designing surveys, and developing statistical models within the software programs R and Excel. In addition to being capable of conducting these types of analyses, I am also able to develop concise summaries of the results of my studies so that they are easily understandable by people who are very busy (e.g. elected officials, department heads, and residents). I have previously given presentations to city council committee meetings, facilitated public workshops, and I appreciate the interaction with the public when I receive input regarding what concerns they would like addressed through recommendations based upon my research.
I find the city’s focus on [specific initiative, e.g., expanding affordable housing, its climate action plan, or its Vision Zero goals] to be especially compelling. I would like nothing more than to assist the city with these initiatives, through analyzing budget trade-offs, studying what other similar cities do well, or assessing whether programs actually produce the desired results. To work in local government is attractive to me since the positive effects of sound policies can be seen quickly: safer streets, affordable housing, and responsive services.
Collaboration is central to how I operate. I have collaborated with engineers, budget officers, legal professionals, and non-profit leaders. I know that successful policies are developed through establishing trust among various departments and with the general public. I am an organized individual who is deadline oriented and capable of handling numerous assignments simultaneously while ensuring accuracy and accountability.
Thank you for taking the time to review my application. I look forward to speaking with you about what I bring to the table in terms of my skills and dedication to providing quality services through the City of [City Name]. Please feel free to contact me via phone at [phone] or email at [email].
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
Show the full output Show less
- GPTZero0.00caught
- Pangram0.00caught
- Winston AI1.00passed
- ZeroGPT0.87passed
- Copyleaks1.00passed
- Originality.ai0.04caught
Passed 3 of 6 detectors.
Every Humbot run in November 2026 →539 words (input 410)
[Your Full Name] [Your Street] [City, ST ZIP Code] [(Telephone Number)] [(E-mail)]
[Date]
[Hiring Manager’s Title] [Department Name] City of [City Name] [Street Address]
Dear [Hiring Manager’s Title]:
I am submitting my application for the Policy Analyst position with the City of [City Name]. As a holder of a Master’s Degree in Public Policy (MPP), with over four years of experience reviewing and advising local decision-making bodies regarding program evaluation and development, I believe I will be able to assist the City of [City Name] develop practical and evidence-based policies that make everyday life better for residents of [City Name].
As a Program Evaluation Specialist at the [Organization Name], I evaluate a variety of regional initiatives related to housing, transportation and public safety for a population of approximately 300,000 people. In 2018-19, I conducted a review of a rental assistance pilot project. The review demonstrated that administrative barriers prevented nearly twenty-percent of eligible households from participating in the pilot. Recommendations that I made to simplify the process and partner with community based organizations to provide outreach resulted in an increase of thirty-five percent in participation over the next six months. This experience has also shown me that as a Policy Analyst, it is critical to balance analytical rigor with an appreciation for the day-to-day operations of programs that serve citizens.
My background includes both quantitative and qualitative research techniques such as cost benefit analyses, survey design, statistical modeling using R and Excel software. Additionally, I have developed strong communication skills to effectively present complex information in a simple format to meet the needs of busy elected officials, departmental leadership and the general public. I have provided formal presentations to various city council committee meetings and have been involved in facilitating public forums, and appreciate the importance of providing an open forum for citizens to share their opinions and ideas.
The City of [City Name]’s focus on [Specific Initiative – i.e. increasing affordable housing, implementing its Climate Action Plan, or achieving its Vision Zero goal(s)], align with many of my professional interests and experiences. I would enjoy the opportunity to contribute to these efforts through conducting fiscal trade-off studies; researching best practices in similar jurisdictions; or evaluating performance metrics to ensure programs are meeting stated objectives.
One aspect of working in local government that appeals to me is the direct impact of effective policy implementation. Good policy yields tangible benefits: improved street conditions; secure and stable housing; responsive municipal services.
To achieve success as a Policy Analyst, I believe collaboration among all stakeholders is essential. In addition to collaborating with other analysts, engineers, budget staff, attorneys and non-profit representatives, I recognize that successful policy development requires building relationships across departmental lines and with members of the public. Organized, deadline driven and capable of managing multiple tasks simultaneously while maintaining high standards of accuracy and clarity, I believe I possess the necessary qualities required to succeed in a collaborative environment.
Thank you for taking the time to consider my application. If given the opportunity, I would appreciate speaking with you about how my skills and passion for serving the public interest could contribute to your organization. Please do not hesitate to contact me at [(telephone)] or [(e-mail)].
Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
Show the full output Show less
- GPTZero0.00caught
- Pangram0.00caught
- Winston AI1.00passed
- ZeroGPT0.60passed
- Copyleaks1.00passed
- Originality.ai0.06caught
Passed 3 of 6 detectors.
Every Walter Writes run in November 2026 →Each chip is one detector's score for that output, from 0 (AI) to 1 (human). A score of 0.50 or higher counts as a pass and shows green; below that the detector caught it and the chip shows red.
Watch the results
How each humanizer did in the November 2026 test, in under a minute.
Stealth Writerwith Adrian Ahmetspahic
Ryne AIwith Zoe Kopidis
Clever AI Humanizerwith Maxwell Bucholz
AI Humanize iowith Ivan Jackson
Walter Writeswith Adrian Ahmetspahic
Undetectable.aiwith Ivan Jackson
SupWriterwith Zoe Kopidis
Phraslywith Maxwell Bucholz
Rephrasywith Zoe Kopidis
WriteHumanwith Maxwell Bucholz
Humbotwith Adrian Ahmetspahic
Grammarlywith Ivan Jackson
StealthGPTwith Adrian Ahmetspahic
Super Humanizerwith Zoe Kopidis
HIX Bypasswith Maxwell Bucholz
Humanize AI Prowith Ivan Jackson
Questions people ask
Is Humbot better than Walter Writes?
Humbot finished 3.4 points ahead of Walter Writes in the November 2026 cycle, 58.38 to 54.95, ranking #13 against #15 in a field of 16. Humbot scored higher on 3 of 6 detectors and 3 of 6 writing categories. Both tools ran the same 30 prompts, scored by the same 6 detectors, under methodology v1.3.0; every input, output and verdict is published.
Which bypasses AI detectors better, Humbot or Walter Writes?
Humbot posted the higher bypass rate, 55.2 vs 54.4, and scored higher on 3 of 6 detectors. Humbot led on Copyleaks, Winston AI and ZeroGPT; Walter Writes led on GPTZero and Originality.ai. The overall bypass gap is inside both 95% confidence intervals, so it is not a reliable difference.
Do Humbot and Walter Writes keep the original meaning?
Humbot preserved meaning better, 77.5 vs 70.7 on our 0–100 similarity scale, though the confidence intervals overlap. On readability, Humbot rated higher, 69.3 vs 63.8. Penalties this cycle: Humbot −10.0, Walter Writes −10.0.